Google vs Microsoft - The fight for the word processor
There seems to be growing speculation about Google’s ability to cause business users the world-over to migrate to using Google’s own cut-down versions of Microsoft’s infamous Office Suit of applications. But let’s take a closer look at how business decisions are made to determine the likelihood of this occurring.
- How many business end-users determine the applications they use within an organization? Many organizations either have their own IT department or outsource IT to a third party. And these IT departments often make decisions based on their own skill-set (probably Microsoft based), its supportability, and security issues, why would they choose Google?
- Security! Lots of businesses like to know their data is sat in their offices. They like to hold a DVD containing all their businesses hard-earned data. After all, all a business is at any time is its data. Will they be comfortable it sitting somewhere on the Internet? – probably many places on the Internet.
- Many end-user applications are no longer stand-alone, and in the future will become even less-so. Microsoft is pushing Sharepoint, furthering back-office integration into front-office applications. This will strengthen the marriage between front/back office systems; bring users various benefits which will make using alternatives feel restrictive. And as before, end-users will probably play little part in deciding back-office systems.
- Everyone agrees Microsoft Office is better – so the argument comes down to one of cost (or Total Cost of Ownership). So do all businesses make decisions purely on cost? It plays a part in many decisions but for astute businesses it’s unlikely to be the only consideration.
- If we look back a few years there where a number of “cheaper” and perfectly good alternatives to applications like MS Word, but why did these loose market share? The fear of receiving a MS Word document from your biggest customer and not being able to read it. Or sending a document and the customer not being able to open it. If you haven’t got any customers then you’ll be fine!
- I, like most people, don’t like being told “you can’t do that” – with MS Office I’m always learning new ways of improving my documents and presentations. I don’t like being limited by a tool. So how will I feel using a cut-down offering? i.e. Will I be searching for an illusive function to draw a circle? The problem is – any word processing or presentation development software will immediately be compared to the industry standard – MS Word & PowerPoint.
- You’ve already bought MS office; you are not going to throw away that investment any time soon. When you look at upgrading you may then consider a move – but what about your investment in back-office infrastructure? Even small businesses probably have MS Small Business Server. It becomes a scary proposition.
But on-line office solutions are great, great for small start-ups and home-users, who will probably continue using them initially as they grow due to historical reliance and stored data. But unfortunately start-up businesses are in the high-risk category and most don’t make it past a few years, so this change will probably be negligible to Microsoft’s current dominance.
I guess time will tell.