My Least Favorite Diamond Shapes for Engagement Rings

Marquise Diamonds

Marquise diamonds have a distinct, elongated shape with pointed ends. They are known for their unique appearance and historical significance.

Features

• Shape: Oval with pointed ends.
• Facets: 56 facets.
• Ideal Ratio: 2:1 length-to-width ratio.

Pros

• Historical Charm: Designed for Louis XIV, inspired by the Marquise de Pompadour's smile.
• Flattering: Makes fingers appear slender.
• Illusion of Size: Appears larger due to its elongated shape.

Cons

• Bow Tie Effect: A dark area in the center can reduce brilliance if not cut well.

Perspectives

• Pro: Some appreciate its historical background and unique look.
• Con: Others find the shape less modern and versatile.

For more on diamond shapes, check out GIA's guide.

Pear-Shaped Diamonds

Pear-shaped diamonds combine elements of round and marquise shapes, often referred to as teardrop diamonds.

Features

• Shape: Round at one end, pointed at the other.
• Ideal Ratio: 1.45 to 1.75 length-to-width ratio.

Pros

• Finger Slimming: Creates an illusion of longer fingers.

Cons

• Less Sparkle: Loses brilliance if poorly proportioned.
• Bow Tie Effect: Difficult to avoid completely.

Perspectives

• Pro: Some find the teardrop shape elegant and unique.
• Con: Others, like myself, find it less appealing due to its reduced sparkle.

For more insights, visit Brilliant Earth's guide.

Heart-Shaped Diamonds

Heart-shaped diamonds are often seen as the most romantic, yet they can be polarizing.

Features

• Shape: Similar to pear but with a cleft at the top.
• Symmetry: Important for aesthetic appeal.

Pros

• Romantic Symbolism: Seen as a symbol of love.
• Cost-Effective: Typically 20%-25% less expensive than round diamonds.

Cons

• Symbolism Overload: Some find it too cliché.
• Less Common: Rarely seen in engagement rings, more in pendants or earrings.

Perspectives

• Pro: Admirers appreciate its romantic symbolism.
• Con: Critics, like myself, find it lacks creativity and sophistication.

For more on heart-shaped diamonds, see Blue Nile's guide.

Conclusion

Choosing a diamond shape is a personal journey. While marquise, pear, and heart shapes have their unique charms, they may not suit everyone's taste. Consider the features, pros, and cons, and explore different perspectives to find the perfect diamond for you. Remember, the best choice is the one that resonates with your personal style and sentiment.