Should complementary and alternative therapies be dismissed so quickly, when many commercially marketed medicines are themselves unproven?
Complementary and alternative therapies (CAMs) are usually considered by the orthodox medical profession to be ‘unproven’ in comparison to prescription drugs. Pharmaceutical products must undergo strict clinical testing to demonstrate their efficacy and safety before being brought to market. Unlike acupuncture, homeopathy and a whole range of other treatments, some going back thousands of years, these drugs have been scientifically proven to work, so we are told.
What then are we to make of the slowly emerging fact that drugs manufacturers can be selective when it comes to publishing the results of clinical trials?
Or that many proven, established commercially produced drugs are at best useless and at worst likely to cause unwanted, sometimes drastic side effects?
Take Prozac, for example – a major anti-depressant, prescribed to millions worldwide. A report published in February 2008 in a US medical journal, Initial Severity and Antidepressant Benefits: A Meta-Analysis of Data Submitted to the Food and Drug Administration, re-examines the preliminary trials done on Prozac and concludes that there is actually no evidence it works.
It is something that frustrates those who are trying to get complementary and alternative treatments accepted by the orthodox medical community. Bruce Hester is Principal Home Treatment adviser for The Arthritic Association, a UK charity dedicated to treating arthritis through natural methods. He said, “Whenever we hear of the withdrawal of a major drug, it’s another nail in the coffin for the idea that there is such as thing as a ‘proven’ treatment. Clearly, many ‘unproven’ treatments are actually more effective that their pharmaceutical alternatives.”
It is not only Prozac that has hit the headlines in recent years. Romozin, used to treat type 2 diabetes, was withdrawn from the UK market in 1997 after a number of serious side effects were recorded in the US and Japan. (See http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/low/uk/36090.stm).
When the arthritis drug Vioxx was withdrawn in 2004, Dr Richard Horton, editor of The Lancet, accused both the US drug regulator and manufacturer Merck of "ruthless, short-sighted and irresponsible self-interest." (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/3983721.stm)
And in November 2007, drug regulators in Britain ordered the withdrawal of another arthritis drug, Prexige, after growing evidence that it was causing liver damage. (http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/health/article2903645.ece)
Bruce Hester knows how hard it is to win credibility beyond the complementary health sector for a health intervention if it is untested in clinical trials. Founded over 65 years ago, The Arthritic Association champions the work of natural health theorist and practitioner Charles de Coti-Marsh and claims his home treatment for arthritis has helped thousands of people to manage their condition without resorting to drugs or surgery.
“It is clear that by publishing only a selection of the results of clinical trials, the situation can arise where there appears to be scientific evidence where none exists,” said Hester. “This makes a mockery of the claim that orthodox medical interventions have been proven to work whereas CAMs have not.”
Top summer tips for managing your arthritis naturally
It is possible to manage the pain of arthritis naturally, and staying active is crucial as it can actually help with pain relief. In this article, an arthritis sufferer tells how he has the condition under control by making changes to his diet and taking moderate exercise.Does rheumatoid arthritis begin in the intestine?
A review of clinical evidence which suggests a link between increased gut permeability with the development of rheumatoid arthritis.Food intolerance and rheumatoid arthritis
Research shows there is a connection between rheumatoid arthritis and food intolerances. This reinforces the findings of Charles de Coti-Marsh, who undertook pioneering research into the causes and treatment of arthritis. He was convinced that what we eat plays a major part in the development of many chronic conditions, including arthritis.