Why "Write About What You Know" Can Be Misleading for Poets

Jan 23
16:18

2025

Lily-Mae Benson

Lily-Mae Benson

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Share this article on Twitter
  • Share this article on Linkedin

"Write about what you know" is a common piece of advice for writers, but for poets, sticking too closely to reality can stifle creativity. Poetry thrives on imagination and the artful manipulation of language, not just factual recounting.

mediaimage

The Pitfalls of Literal Truth in Poetry

  • Overemphasis on Facts: Focusing too much on real-life details can clutter a poem. Poetry is about distilling emotions and ideas,Why not reporting events.
  • Personal Attachment: Holding onto personal experiences can lead to irrelevant details that don't resonate with a wider audience.

Example: Meeting Your Partner

Imagine writing a poem about meeting your spouse. While this is a relatable theme, the specifics can bog down the poem:

  • Details to Consider:

    • Was it important that it was a "wet Tuesday"? Perhaps "Wednesday" or "Thursday" fits better rhythmically.
    • Does the exact time matter? "Monday morning" or "Thursday at three" might offer better imagery.
  • Sound and Rhythm: Consider how The Crystals' song "Da Doo Ron Ron" uses sound. The "m" sounds in "met," "him," and "Monday" create a cohesive line. The Crystals' Song

  • Imagery: "Seagull Grove" is a charming name, but unless it ties into the poem's theme, it might distract rather than enhance.

Balancing Truth and Creativity

  • Selective Detailing: Choose details that enhance the poem's mood and message. Manipulate facts to serve the poem's artistic needs.
  • Avoiding Literalism: Remember, poetry isn't journalism. It's about evoking feelings and thoughts, not just recounting events.

Perspectives on Poetic Truth

  1. Traditional View: Some argue that personal truth adds authenticity. It can ground a poem in reality, making it relatable.
  2. Creative View: Others believe that poetry should transcend reality, using imagination to explore universal themes.

Interesting Stats

  • Poetry's Popularity: According to the National Endowment for the Arts, poetry readership in the U.S. increased by 76% from 2012 to 2017. NEA Report
  • Creative Writing Trends: A 2020 survey found that 60% of poets believe that creativity is more important than factual accuracy in their work. Creative Writing Survey

Conclusion

When writing poetry, let creativity guide you. Use personal experiences as a springboard, but don't let them confine you. Craft your poem with an eye for sound, rhythm, and imagery, and remember that sometimes, bending the truth can lead to a more compelling piece.