Why Did Snape Kill Dumbledore?

Dec 12
07:15

2023

Jane Scaplen

Jane Scaplen

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Share this article on Twitter
  • Share this article on Linkedin

Severus Snape, a name that echoes through the chambers of Hogwarts, stirring feelings of intrigue, mystery, and controversy among the Wizarding World and readers alike. A man cloaked in shadows, whose actions sparked debates and whose loyalties beguiled many. Was he a villain, a hero, or perhaps something in between? As we delve into his perplexing tale, a web of loyalty, love, sacrifice, and redemption unravels, revealing the man behind the enigma. One question that often arises is, why did Snape kill Dumbledore?

This pivotal moment in the story adds even more complexity to his character and the overall narrative.

Key Takeaways

  • Severus Snape’s loyalty was complex and multifaceted,Why Did Snape Kill Dumbledore? Articles ranging from devotion to Voldemort to sacrificing himself for the cause of Dumbledore.
  • The Killing Curse sealed Snape’s fate as he sought redemption by protecting Harry Potter from harm.
  • His actions led to his ultimate redemption, though it is still a highly debated topic among fans.

The Complex Loyalty of Severus Snape

Severus Snape and Albus Dumbledore Severus Snape, a figure as enigmatic as the dark corridors of Hogwarts, bore a loyalty as intricate as the castle’s shifting staircases. Initially, Snape was a fervent follower of the Dark Lord, Voldemort, rallying under the banner of the Death Eaters. Beneath the eerie glow of the Dark Mark, Snape pledged his loyalty to a cause that sowed seeds of fear and destruction across the Wizarding World. But loyalty, much like magic, can be deceptive.

Nonetheless, Snape experienced a profound shift in allegiance that ushered him onto a treacherous path of danger and sacrifice. He began to serve as a covert operative for Albus Dumbledore, the esteemed Hogwarts Headmaster, who was the beacon of resistance against the Dark Lord. This change was not a simple switch of sides in a magical war. Instead, it marked the beginning of a complex journey of redemption, fueled by a love that transcended time and death - his love for Lily Potter.

Snape’s devotion to Dumbledore was unwavering, even when it demanded the ultimate sacrifice. He carried out a deed that sent shockwaves through the magical realm – he killed Albus Dumbledore. This act, as heinous as it appeared, was performed at the request of Dumbledore himself. But why would Dumbledore ask Snape to murder him, and why would Snape agree? The answers to these questions reveal a complex interplay of promises, protection, and a quest for redemption.

The Unbreakable Vow and Its Consequences

In the complex web of motives and actions woven throughout the Harry Potter series, one pivotal thread is the Unbreakable Vow. As the name suggests, this magical agreement is binding, unyielding, and if broken, the consequences are fatal. Snape, under the watchful eyes of Narcissa Malfoy and Bellatrix Lestrange, entered into such a vow, promising to protect Draco Malfoy and to eliminate Dumbledore if the young Malfoy could not complete the task.

Consequently, the Unbreakable Vow left Snape in a perilous situation. As he watched Draco struggle with the task of assassinating Dumbledore, Snape knew the consequences of a failed Unbreakable Vow. He was aware that Draco’s failed attempts to kill Dumbledore, from a cursed necklace to a poisoned wine bottle, reflected his hesitance and inner turmoil. Snape understood that the young Malfoy was not a killer, and so, with the weight of the vow hanging heavy on him, he stepped in to fulfill the Dark Lord’s command.

Dumbledore's Fateful Request

Dumbledore, the beacon of wisdom and guidance in the Harry Potter series, was not just the victim of a dark curse but also a strategist playing a long game. Aware of the curse gnawing at his life, Dumbledore made a shocking request of Snape: he asked him to kill Albus Dumbledore when Dumbledore died. This plea was not born out of fear or surrender, but out of a desire to protect Draco from the soul-damaging act of murder and to spare himself from a painful death. In the end, Dumbledore’s death served a greater purpose than just the culmination of a tragic tale, and the act of killing Dumbledore became a pivotal moment in the story.

Snape, bound by his loyalty to Dumbledore and his vow to protect Draco, found himself at the crossroads of duty and morality. He agreed to carry out Dumbledore’s request, thus setting in motion a chain of events that would redefine his character and change the course of the Wizarding World. Snape’s choice to kill Dumbledore was not an act of treachery, but rather a painful sacrifice made in the name of loyalty and the greater good.

The Greater Good: Protecting Harry Potter

In the intricate tapestry of Snape’s loyalties, one thread stands out – his commitment to protecting Harry Potter. Snape’s ultimate objective was to shield Harry from harm and ensure Voldemort’s downfall. This mission was not driven by an affection for Harry, but rather by his enduring love for Lily Potter, Harry’s mother.

When the time came for Snape to fulfill Dumbledore’s request, he did so with a heavy heart and a steady hand. On the Astronomy Tower, under a sky littered with stars, Snape ended Dumbledore’s life with the Killing Curse. It was a merciful end to Dumbledore’s suffering, made more poignant by the fact that Snape, a man many considered a villain, carried out this act of mercy.

The Curse That Sealed His Fate

Cursed Ring In the world of magic, curses carry a heavy weight. For Snape, one curse sealed his fate, setting him on a path from which there was no return. The Killing Curse, a spell synonymous with death, became an integral part of Snape’s story. When he uttered the curse and ended Dumbledore’s life, he embraced a destiny steeped in sacrifice and redemption.

Snape’s use of the Killing Curse, however, did not change his role within the series. Instead, it highlighted his readiness to use dark magic, illuminating the darker aspects of his character. It was the use of another curse, Sectumsempra, that further defined his character, revealing his willingness to cause harm and his proficiency in the Dark Arts.

Interestingly, the curse on the Defense Against the Dark Arts position did not directly influence Snape’s affiliations or loyalties. Instead, his loyalty to Lily Potter, a woman he loved but lost, had a profound effect on his choices and alliances. Despite his association with the Dark Arts, Snape’s true allegiance lay with Lily, and by extension, Harry, demonstrating his complex and multifaceted loyalty.

The Horcrux Hunt

The search for Horcruxes, the pieces of Voldemort’s soul, forms a significant part of the Harry Potter series. Dumbledore’s quest to unearth these ominous tokens led him to Marvolo Gaunt’s ring, a hexed artifact that induced his gradual, agonizing demise. This cursed ring and the Horcrux it contained were crucial elements in Snape’s story.

When Dumbledore donned the cursed ring, he succumbed to a powerful curse that slowly started to claim his life. Snape, with his exceptional knowledge of the Dark Arts, managed to create a ‘golden potion’ that temporarily contained the curse. However, he could not halt the curse’s progression, making Dumbledore’s death inevitable. This tragic turn of events set the stage for Snape’s most controversial act – the killing of Albus Dumbledore.

A Headmaster's Sacrifice

As the curse from the Horcrux ring tightened its grip on Dumbledore, the headmaster made a series of plans to ensure the safety of his students and the future of the Wizarding World. He entrusted Snape with a crucial task, a request that would test Snape’s allegiance and loyalty to the fullest.

Aware of his dwindling hours, Dumbledore entrusted Snape with the task of ending his life when the right moment arrived. This request was not just about avoiding a painful death, but also about saving Draco from becoming a murderer and preserving Snape’s position as a trusted Death Eater. Snape, bound by his loyalty to Dumbledore and the Unbreakable Vow, agreed to this request, thus preparing himself to make the ultimate sacrifice.

The Final Act on the Astronomy Tower

Astronomy Tower at Hogwarts The Astronomy Tower, a place of learning and exploration, became the stage for one of the most pivotal moments in the Harry Potter series. Under the starlit sky, Snape made a choice that would forever define his character in the eyes of the Wizarding World. The moment of Snape raising his wand against Dumbledore remains seared into the memories of every reader.

Young Draco Malfoy, a student torn between his family’s dark legacy and his own conscience, found himself unable to kill Dumbledore. This hesitation signaled a shift in Draco’s character, showing that he was not entirely lost to the dark side. It also provided Snape, the Half Blood Prince, with an opportunity to step in and fulfill his Unbreakable Vow, thereby protecting Draco from becoming a murderer.

Snape’s use of the Killing Curse on Dumbledore marked the end of an era. It was a merciful end for Dumbledore, who was already dying from a curse. However, it was also a beginning – the start of a period where Snape’s true loyalties and sacrifices would come to light, revealing the man behind the mask.

Draco Malfoy's Reluctance

The task of murdering Dumbledore weighed heavily on Draco Malfoy. Despite his bravado and his desperate attempts to prove himself to Voldemort and his Death Eater parents, Draco found himself hesitating when the moment arrived. He was, after all, still a teenager, thrust into a dark world that he was not fully prepared for.

This reluctance to carry out the murder was not a sign of weakness but rather a testament to Draco’s conflicted character. Despite his upbringing and the expectations placed upon him, Draco showed a glimmer of humanity, hinting at the potential for change. This hesitance provided Snape with the opportunity he needed to step in and fulfill the Unbreakable Vow he had made to protect Draco.

The Killing Curse: A Merciful End

In the world of Harry Potter, the Killing Curse, Avada Kedavra, is a spell that holds a certain finality. It is a dark spell that instantly ends the life of the person it is cast upon, leaving no trace of physical harm on the victim’s body. When Snape pointed his wand at Dumbledore, he chose a swift and merciful end for the headmaster.

Snape’s use of the Killing Curse on Dumbledore, often referred to as “snape killing dumbledore,” did not stem from a desire for power or from an act of betrayal. Instead, it was an act of mercy, a way to end Dumbledore’s suffering from the curse of the Horcrux ring. By using the Killing Curse, Snape ensured that Dumbledore’s death was quick and painless. In a way, Snape’s use of the Killing Curse was the final act of loyalty towards the man he respected and served.

The Aftermath and Legacy of Snape's Deed

Elder Wand The repercussions of Snape’s act echoed through the halls of Hogwarts and the wider Wizarding World. Dumbledore’s death marked the end of an era and the beginning of a time of uncertainty and fear. However, it also set the stage for the ultimate showdown between Harry and Voldemort. Snape’s actions, while controversial, played a crucial role in the final battle.

Snape’s murder of Dumbledore had far-reaching effects, beyond what anyone could have anticipated. It inadvertently transferred the Elder Wand’s allegiance to Snape, setting the stage for the final battle between Harry and Voldemort. Snape’s actions, while controversial, played a crucial role in the events that led to Voldemort’s downfall.

The reverberations of Snape’s act continue to resonate throughout the series. After learning the truth about Snape’s actions and his role in defeating Voldemort, Harry chose to honor Snape by naming his son after him. This gesture marked a significant shift in Harry’s perception of Snape and demonstrated his recognition of Snape’s sacrifices.

The Elder Wand's Allegiance

The Elder Wand, one of the Deathly Hallows, is a symbol of power and supremacy. Its allegiance is not won by inheritance or chance, but by the defeat of its previous master. When Snape killed Dumbledore, it was assumed that the wand’s loyalty would shift to him. However, the true allegiance of the wand remained a mystery until the final stages of the series.

The Elder Wand’s allegiance played a pivotal role in the final battle between Harry and Voldemort. The wand refused to harm Harry, its true master, and turned on Voldemort instead. Snape’s murder of Dumbledore had, therefore, unintentionally set the stage for the ultimate confrontation. It was yet another example of how Snape’s actions, driven by his loyalty to Dumbledore and his love for Lily, were instrumental in Voldemort’s downfall.

Harry Potter's Tribute

In the aftermath of the final battle, Harry Potter paid a poignant tribute to Snape. Despite their tumultuous relationship and Snape’s harsh treatment of him, Harry recognized the sacrifices that Snape had made. He realized that Snape’s actions, no matter how questionable they seemed at the time, were driven by his love for Lily and his desire to ensure Voldemort’s defeat.

Harry’s tribute to Snape came in the form of a name. He named his second son Albus Severus Potter, honoring two of the bravest men he knew – Albus Dumbledore and Severus Snape. This gesture signified Harry’s forgiveness and understanding of Snape’s actions. It was a nod to Snape’s role in the battle against Voldemort and a recognition of his unrequited love for Lily.

The Controversy Surrounding Severus Snape

Severus Snape's Love and Loss Snape’s actions in the Harry Potter series have sparked numerous debates and discussions among fans. The controversy surrounding Snape’s character stems from his actions, his motives, and his ultimate redemption. Some fans view Snape as a hero, a double agent who risked everything to bring down Voldemort. Others see him as a complex character, torn between his love for Lily and his loyalty to Dumbledore.

Another point of contention among fans is the treatment of students at Hogwarts. Snape’s favoritism towards the Slytherin house and his harsh treatment of the Gryffindor students, particularly Harry, Hermione, and Neville, have been widely criticized. Some fans argue that Snape’s actions were a result of his difficult childhood and his unrequited love for Lily. Others, however, believe that his behavior was inexcusable and see him as a flawed character.

Despite the controversies, there is no denying that Snape’s character added a layer of complexity to the series. His actions, driven by his love for Lily and his desire for redemption, played a crucial role in the defeat of Voldemort. Whether one views him as a hero or a villain, Snape’s character is undeniably one of the most intriguing in the Harry Potter series.

A Life Marked by Love and Loss

Snape’s life was a tapestry woven with threads of love and loss. The love he had for Lily Potter was a driving force behind many of his actions. Even though his love was unrequited, it influenced his decisions and shaped his life. Snape’s love for Lily was a beacon that guided him through the darkest times of his life.

The loss of Lily was a turning point for Snape. It marked the end of his association with the Death Eaters and the beginning of his allegiance to Dumbledore. Snape’s love for Lily transcended death, influencing his actions long after she was gone. From safeguarding Harry to orchestrating a pivotal role in Voldemort’s downfall, Snape’s deeds bore witness to his undying love for Lily.

The Question of Redemption

The question of Snape’s redemption is a topic of heated debate among fans. His actions, particularly his treatment of Harry and his role in Dumbledore’s death, have been scrutinized and judged. Some fans believe that his actions were justified, given his love for Lily and his role in defeating Voldemort. They argue that Snape’s sacrifices and his ultimate death were acts of redemption.

On the other hand, some fans criticize Snape’s actions, arguing that his obsession with Lily and his harsh treatment of students at Hogwarts were not justified. They question whether Snape’s actions were truly redeemable. Despite the varying perspectives, it is undeniable that Snape’s character underwent a significant transformation throughout the series. From a Death Eater to a double agent, Snape’s journey was one marked by love, loss, and ultimately, redemption.

Summary

Severus Snape, a name that stirs up a whirlwind of emotions and debates among the Harry Potter fandom, is a character whose true intentions were cloaked in mystery until the very end. From his initial allegiance to Voldemort and the Death Eaters to his shift in loyalty to Dumbledore and the Order of the Phoenix, Snape’s journey is a testament to the complex nature of the human spirit.

His love for Lily Potter, his decision to protect Harry, his role in Dumbledore’s death, and his ultimate sacrifice in the battle against Voldemort all contribute to the multifaceted character that is Severus Snape. Whether seen as a hero, a villain, or something in between, Snape’s character adds a layer of complexity and depth to the Harry Potter series that continues to captivate fans worldwide.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why exactly did Snape kill Dumbledore?

In order to protect Draco Malfoy from emotional trauma and prove his loyalty to Lord Voldemort, Snape agreed to kill Dumbledore himself if the youngster was unable to do so.

Why did Dumbledore let himself die?

Dumbledore sacrificed himself to motivate Harry Potter and set in motion the events to defeat Voldemort, while accepting his own fate as he was already dying from a curse.

Why did Voldemort kill Snape?

Voldemort had to kill Snape in order to take ownership of the Elder Wand, since Snape killed Dumbledore and was, in Voldemort's eyes, a replaceable follower. Voldemort needed the wand's allegiance to switch in order to fulfill his mission.

What was the Unbreakable Vow Snape made?

Snape made an Unbreakable Vow to protect Draco Malfoy and kill Dumbledore if need be.

Was Snape's love for Lily Potter genuine?

Yes, Snape's love for Lily Potter was genuine and deep-rooted, being a major motivating factor behind his actions throughout the series.