Who Embellishes More During An Interview?

Oct 25

10:18

2009

Brad Remillard

Candidates or hiring managers? If you get 10 or more CEO's and key executives in a room and ask, "What percent of candidates embellish in the hiring process?" you will hear anything from the conservative 80% to the more skeptical 100%. I don't know if there have been any studies on this topic, but most would agree the number is over 50%. Whatever the percentage is, it doesn't matter, when you consider the following.

Hiring managers generally wait until they need a person to begin the hiring process. It can take 2 or 3 months to hire a person. By this time most hiring managers are desperate to hire a person. So then, with a hiring manager desperate to hire someone, some hiring managers start to sell more than interview. The results are often "embellishing" by the hiring manager. OK, "What percent of hiring managers embellish during the hiring process?" Even if it is 50% what impact does this have on the interview?

Simply put, if in an interview candidates embellish 50% of the time and hiring managers embellish 50% of the time, too often everyone is lying to each other about the position or their ability to do the job. Is it any wonder why most interviews are a waste of time? Is it a surprise that so often when the candidate shows up for work, hiring managers say, "You're not the person I hired."

There are a number of things hiring managers can do to reduce embellishment. Two simple things are:

Become proactive in your hiring. 80% of the time most hiring managers know in advance a position may need to be filled. Instead of waiting until the need is critical, start the process sooner. When there is a potential need begin the process at least passively. Start developing a queue of candidates, ask others if they know of anyone, review some of the free internet networking sites such as Linkedin, attend networking meetings that potential candidates attend, and when appropriate tap into current employee's networks. You don't have to be reactive which causes "desperation" hiring.
Prepare a structured interview that probes deeply. This will help to avoid the selling rather than interviewing syndrome. When hiring managers have a structured set of questions specifically designed to test the candidate's ability to deliver a standard of performance, the probability of candidate embellishment will be much more difficult.

Eliminating embellishment on both sides will dramatically change both the quality of interviews and the results.

I welcome your thoughts and comments.

Article "tagged" as: