Why Was Stevia Banned and Is It Safe Now?

Oct 9
03:01

2024

Jane Scaplen

Jane Scaplen

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Share this article on Twitter
  • Share this article on Linkedin

In 1991, the FDA banned stevia due to potential cancer risks and insufficient safety data. Let's explore why was stevia banned, how new research changed its status, and its current safety.

Key Takeaways

  • Stevia was initially banned by the FDA in 1991 due to concerns about its potential carcinogenic risks and insufficient safety data,Why Was Stevia Banned and Is It Safe Now? Articles but this ban was lifted in 2008 as new research demonstrated its safety.
  • High-purity stevia extracts are classified as Generally Recognized as Safe (GRAS) by the FDA, making them suitable for use in various food products, while crude extracts and whole leaves remain unapproved.
  • Ongoing scientific research has mitigated early health concerns related to stevia, revealing potential health benefits and confirming its safety when consumed within established limits.

Why Was Stevia Banned and Is It Safe Now?

An illustration depicting the stevia plant, highlighting its leaves and flowers, with a subtle background hinting at the topic of why was stevia banned.

Extracted from the Stevia rebaudiana plant, stevia serves as a natural sweetener and was once prohibited by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in the United States due to initial health concerns, including suspicions of it being carcinogenic. In 1991, preliminary research triggered caution regarding its use after showing questionable safety evidence.

By 2008, advancements in scientific understanding led to a revised viewpoint from the FDA. The agency began permitting both stevia leaves and its extracts for incorporation into dietary supplements following more conclusive studies that allayed earlier fears about their safety.

In present times, high-purity extracts of stevia are considered safe for consumption with an official Recognized As Safe (GRAS) status granted by the FDA. This endorsement has allowed widespread utilization of stevia as a favored sweetener across various products.

Introduction

The transformation of stevia from an ancient sweetening agent employed by native tribes in South America to a contemporary sugar substitute is intriguing. Stevia, derived from the leaves of the Stevia rebaudiana plant, has been valued for its intense sweetness over hundreds of years. Despite being naturally sourced, stevia encountered substantial hurdles with regulatory bodies—most notably when it was prohibited by the FDA in the early 1990s amidst health concerns.

These initial fears regarding possible reproductive issues and mutagenic properties were sufficiently troubling to necessitate intervention by authorities. Yet subsequent studies improved our comprehension of stevia and mitigated these fears, ultimately leading to a reverse in its legal standing as research provided clarity on these matters.

Our blog will guide you through each chapter in the storied history of stevia—from facing prohibitions to enjoying widespread acceptance—and delve into detailed discussions surrounding its safety profile and advantages as a sweetener.

Understanding Stevia

An artistic representation of stevia leaves and a sugar substitute comparison, emphasizing the natural sweetener aspect.

Derived from the Stevia rebaudiana plant, a shrub native to South America, stevia serves as a natural sugar substitute. Its leaves are known for their intense sweetness and have been utilized as an alternative to sugar for many years. As opposed to artificial sweeteners, stevia is derived from nature, presenting an appealing choice for individuals aiming to cut down on sugar consumption without using synthetic substitutes.

Within the Stevia rebaudiana resides compounds named steviol glycosides that give the leaf its sweet flavor. These are then extracted and refined into what we know as stevia extracts available in various forms including powders, liquids, or tablets.

Stevia’s ascent in popularity stems from its role as a low calorie sweetener compared with traditional options. It offers desired sweetness minus adverse health effects linked with high-sugar diets.

Early Concerns Over Stevia Safety

A creative visual showing early concerns over stevia safety, featuring a stevia plant with caution symbols.

Initial studies raised alarms about stevia’s safety, pointing to possible detrimental impacts on reproductive health and the potential for mutagenicity, which is the capacity to induce genetic alterations. These disturbing results were significant enough to catch the attention of the FDA and prompt a response.

Concerns over stevia extended beyond its effects on reproduction. Apprehension grew with evidence from animal studies suggesting that it might have mutagenic properties. This contributed to a wider concern among consumers regarding steavia as potentially hazardous until Research could provide more definitive answers pertaining to these initial findings.

Initial FDA Ban in 1991

In the initial stages of stevia’s examination, early investigations raised concerns regarding its use as a food additive, prompting the FDA to impose a ban on it in 1991. The prohibition was grounded on fears about potential carcinogenicity and an insufficient amount of toxicological data to deem stevia safe for consumption. This decision represented a pivotal moment in how stevia would be managed within the regulatory framework, leading to its classification as an ‘unsafe food additive’.

The action taken by the FDA was shaped by research that hinted at a correlation between stevia usage and cancer risk. These findings were not definitive. Consequently, this restriction stayed effective pending additional scientific inquiry aimed at securing more conclusive evidence concerning the safety profile of stevia.

Health Concerns

Initial apprehensions regarding stevia usage were notable due to certain health concerns. Preliminary research raised red flags about its possible adverse influences on reproductive well-being, including implications for fertility. The observed mutagenic characteristics in these early investigations sparked worry over the extended genetic ramifications linked with consuming stevia.

The consumption of unprocessed variants of steavia, like whole leaves and crude extracts, drew heightened scrutiny because they contain elements whose effects were not comprehensively known at that time. The presence of such compounds contributed to a cautious atmosphere and doubt concerning employing stevia as an alternative natural sweetener.

Regulatory Landscape of Stevia

An infographic-style illustration summarizing the regulatory landscape of stevia across different regions.

Over time, the regulatory environment surrounding stevia has undergone substantial changes, shaped by continual scientific study and differing laws across regions. Although stevia was once prohibited by the FDA in the United States, it remained a popular ingredient without negative health consequences reported in nations such as Japan and Brazil. This disparity underscores the complexities involved in regulating natural substances like stevia that can be swayed by national scientific assessments and vested economic interests.

Presently, numerous countries have recognized various forms of stevia as safe for consumption due to rigorous safety examinations and updates to regulations. It is essential for consumers to stay informed about their own country’s stance on stevia to ensure they make knowledgeable decisions regarding its usage.

United States

Over time, the United States’ stance on stevia has evolved significantly. In a notable shift in 2008, the FDA changed its position and acknowledged that certain purified extracts of stevia, including rebaudioside A specifically, were safe for human consumption. This regulatory alteration was groundbreaking as it permitted both the importation and utilization of stevia leaves and their derivatives within dietary supplements.

Subsequently, specific purified extractions from stevia have been recognized by the FDA as Recognized As Safe (GRAS), which enables these substances to be included in an array of food products without necessitating Safety evaluations. The assignment of GRAS status to these purified extracts has facilitated broad acceptance and use of this non-caloric sweetener across various sectors within the American market.

European Union

In the European Union, the status of stevia has undergone considerable evolution. Previously prohibited until 2011, it was ultimately the comprehensive safety assessment of steviol glycosides by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) that facilitated a change in stance. This led to lifting the prohibition and endorsing steviol glycosides for incorporation into food products.

Notwithstanding this progress, it is essential to recognize that entire leaves from the stevia plant remain unauthorized for employment in food items within EU boundaries. Authorization extends exclusively to refined extracts like steviol glycosides obtained from the plant, which are permitted for use.

Other Countries

The regulatory environment for stevia, a natural sweetener, differs greatly across the globe. In Japan, stevia has been used safely for many years, which demonstrates a markedly different attitude from initial U.S. regulations regarding its use. Conversely, Singapore’s stringent prohibition on stevia illustrates the wide spectrum of positions taken by countries concerning this sweetener.

Nowadays, numerous nations have approved the use of steivia based on updated safety evaluations and research advancements in many countries now permit its use. This widespread endorsement emphasizes that continual scientific analysis is vital in influencing how the regulatory framework for this natural sweetener develops internationally.

Scientific Research on Stevia Safety

An illustration depicting scientific research on stevia safety, with lab equipment and stevia extracts, emphasizing health benefits.

Extensive scientific research has significantly altered the understanding of stevia’s safety profile. Over time, a multitude of studies aimed at examining early worries about its potential health risks have taken place, exploring concerns from possible carcinogenic effects to general health implications.

Regulatory bodies such as the FDA have recognized high-purity steviol glycosides sourced from the stevia rebaudiana plant as safe for use in food and beverages. This endorsement by authorities has facilitated the broad incorporation of naturally-derived stevia extracts into an array of products ranging from powdered forms to liquid sweeteners, presenting people with a secure and natural alternative for sugar replacement.

Studies Addressing Cancer Risks

Early research prompted the FDA to prohibit stevia in 1991, citing a potential risk of cancer. The preliminary findings pointed to possible connections between stevia and reproductive health issues, casting doubts on its safety as a food additive.

Nevertheless, subsequent investigations have not substantiated any clear link between moderate consumption of steavia and cancer risk. These studies imply that steviol glycosides might even exhibit anti-cancer qualities in specific types of cancer cells. This progressive accumulation of evidence has mitigated former apprehensions and bolstered confidence in the safety profile of stevia.

General Safety and Health Benefits

Research has not only tackled particular health worries, but also shed light on the possible advantages of stevia, such as aiding in weight control and possibly reducing blood pressure. The role it plays in traditional remedies for diabetes and regulating blood sugar emphasizes its therapeutic promise.

Having recognized these attributes, the European Food Safety Authority has set a safe level for daily consumption of steviol glycosides. This allows people to benefit from stevia’s qualities safely — enhancing its reputation as a natural sweetener that provides low calories while having little effect on blood sugar.

Forms of Stevia and Their Safety

Stevia comes in various forms, and each possesses a distinct safety level. The two primary forms include high-purity stevia extracts and crude stevia extracts. The former is known for its abundant content of steviol glycosides and has gained widespread acceptance due to the recognition of its safety by regulatory bodies such as the FDA, which approves their use within food products.

Contrastingly, crude steivia extracts along with whole leaves have not received approval from the FDA to be used in food items because there isn’t enough data affirming their safety. For those looking to incorporate stevia into their diet safely, it’s essential to discern between these different types of preparations.

Purified Stevia Extracts

Extracts of stevia, specifically those identified as high-purity steviol glycosides obtained from the Stevia rebaudiana plant leaves, have been subjected to rigorous safety assessments. These purified extracts have achieved Recognized As Safe (GRAS) status authorized by the FDA, signifying that they are approved for use in a variety of food products without the necessity for Safety examinations. Consequently, these purified forms of stevia provide a trustworthy and safe substitute for conventional sugar.

Investigations into its health effects reveal no substantial evidence indicating any carcinogenic risk associated with consuming recommended amounts of stevia. Food items labeled with “stevia extract” or “Stevia rebaudiana” signal their origin from these non-hazardous refined versions of the plant’s extract. Purified extracts’ recognized security has thus rendered them a favored option among customers seeking natural sweetening alternatives.

Crude Stevia Extracts and Leaves

Regulatory agencies have granted a different status to purified stevia extracts compared to crude steiva extracts and whole leaves of the plant. The latter two, due to lack of adequate toxicological information, are not authorized by the FDA as food additives. These raw forms might include substances absent in refined products that could pose health hazards.

Contrary to what might be assumed given their natural source, both crude stevia extracts and entire leaves do not meet FDA standards for safe consumption. It is advised that consumers seeking assurance of safety with regards to consuming this sweetener should choose items explicitly labeled as containing high-purity stevia extract, thereby sidestepping any potential negative effects. Comprehending these differences is crucial when selecting products that involve the use of stevia.

Economic and Industry Influences

Economic considerations, along with scientific studies, have played a pivotal role in the regulation of stevia. Concerned about potential losses in market share, the sugar industry has historically campaigned against the wide acceptance and use of steiva. Similarly, key players within beverage companies have lobbied to counteract regulations that might limit their use of alternative sweeteners like stevia.

These lobbying activities are strategically designed to sway regulatory agencies towards policies favorable to industry profits by maintaining consistent sales figures for diet products containing such substitutes. Consequently, this interplay between commerce and science results in varying degrees of legal approval for stevia across different regions.

The intricate balance between scientific research findings, governmental rule-making processes, and corporate agendas is central to determining both access to and approval for market introduction of non-traditional sweetening agents like stevia.

Consumer Awareness and Guidance

It is essential for consumers to be aware of the regulatory status and safety standards pertaining to stevia products. Given that different types of stevia have distinct regulations and levels of safety, having accurate information is vital when making decisions about purchasing these products.

The following content offers advice on how to choose stevia products that are safe while ensuring compliance with the advised limits on daily consumption.

Choosing Safe Stevia Products

Consumers opting for stevia as a natural sweetener should prioritize products that feature high-purity extracts of the plant. Such products have a higher likelihood of adhering to safety and regulatory guidelines. Look out for labeling that indicates high-purity stevia extract or mentions its Recognized As Safe (GRAS) status, which adds an extra layer of confidence in product safety.

It is recommended to steer clear from food items containing crude extracts or whole leaves from the stevia plant since these types have not received approval by the FDA for use in foodstuffs. By selecting only those offerings with refined stevia extracts, consumers are able to enjoy this sweetening option safely without risk to their health.

Recommended Daily Intake

The Food and Drug Administration has established a safe consumption threshold for steviol glycosides, identified as an acceptable daily intake (ADI) of 4 milligrams per kilogram of body weight. Following this guideline is crucial for individuals to appreciate the advantages of stevia safely without running into any health concerns associated with excessive use.

It’s important for consumers to keep track of their cumulative intake from various sources such as dietary supplements and products sweetened with stevia. By adhering to the ADI recommended by authorities, people can take pleasure in using stevia as a reliable alternative to sugar while ensuring they remain within safe consumption limits.

Summary

The journey of stevia from a banned substance to a widely accepted natural sweetener highlights the importance of scientific research and regulatory oversight. Initially banned by the FDA in 1991 due to health concerns, stevia’s safety was later reaffirmed through extensive studies and evaluations. Today, high-purity stevia extracts are recognized as safe for consumption and are used in a variety of food products.

Consumers can confidently choose stevia products by looking for high-purity extracts and adhering to recommended intake levels. As a natural, low-calorie sweetener, stevia offers a safe alternative to traditional sugar, allowing consumers to enjoy sweetness without the associated health risks. This evolution underscores the dynamic nature of food safety regulations and the ongoing efforts to provide safe, healthy options for consumers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why was stevia initially banned by the FDA?

Due to potential health hazards, including associations with cancer and reproductive issues, the FDA prohibited Stevia in 1991, exercising prudence over the safety of natural sweeteners.

Is stevia safe to consume now?

Stevia is safe to consume, as high-purity extracts have received GRAS status from the FDA, permitting their use in food products.

You can confidently include stevia in your diet.

What are the different forms of stevia and their safety profiles?

The different forms of stevia include high-purity extracts, which are FDA-approved and deemed safe, and crude extracts or whole leaves, which are not approved due to inadequate safety data.

It is important to choose only high-purity extracts for safe consumption.

How can consumers choose safe stevia products?

To ensure the safety of stevia products, consumers should select high-purity stevia extracts and avoid crude extracts or whole leaves.

Additionally, choosing products labeled with GRAS status will provide extra assurance of safety.

What is the recommended daily intake for stevia?

According to the FDA, safe consumption levels of stevia are maintained by adhering to a recommended daily intake of 4 milligrams per kilogram of body weight.

Following this recommendation helps individuals preserve their health while still being able to enjoy the sweetener.