Why Insurance Firms Have Left the Irish Market

Jan 21
05:23

2025

David Stave

David Stave

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Share this article on Twitter
  • Share this article on Linkedin

Insurance companies have been leaving the Irish market at an alarming rate, causing concern among business owners and policymakers. Nearly 248 companies have exited over the past six years, with more than half leaving in the last two years. This trend has led to increased insurance premiums, adding financial strain to businesses, especially in sectors like hospitality. The government is working to address these issues, but understanding the reasons behind these exits is crucial.

mediaimage

Key Reasons for Exiting the Irish Market

  • High Claims and Costs: Many companies,Why Insurance Firms Have Left the Irish Market Articles such as Axis and AIG, cite high insurance claims as a primary reason for their exit. These claims increase operational costs, making it difficult to maintain profitability. However, some argue that if claims were truly excessive, profits wouldn't be as high as reported. Source: Irish Times

  • Regulatory Scrutiny: The Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) has been investigating the insurance sector's practices. This scrutiny may have prompted some companies to leave, fearing potential regulatory changes that could impact their operations. Source: CCPC

  • Brexit and EU Passporting: The UK's exit from the EU has complicated matters for companies operating under EU passporting rules. Many smaller operators find the process of seeking new authorization cumbersome and costly, leading them to withdraw from the Irish market. Source: Financial Times

Impact on Businesses and Consumers

  • Increased Premiums: With fewer insurers in the market, remaining companies have raised premiums. This increase affects business owners' financial security and operational sustainability.

  • Limited Options: Businesses face challenges in renewing policies or finding affordable coverage. This situation is particularly dire for small businesses that cannot absorb high insurance costs.

Government and Industry Response

  • CIWG Recommendations: The Cost of Insurance Working Group (CIWG) has suggested inviting non-life insurers to enter the Irish market. Implementing these recommendations could provide more affordable options for consumers.

  • Potential Solutions: Policymakers are exploring measures to stabilize the market and ensure small businesses can access necessary insurance without prohibitive costs.

Different Perspectives

  • Business Owners' View: Many business owners feel trapped by rising costs and limited options. They worry about their ability to compete and sustain operations without affordable insurance.

  • Insurers' Perspective: Insurance companies argue that high claims and regulatory pressures make the market unviable. They seek a more balanced environment where they can operate profitably.

Interesting Stats

  • Insurance Premiums: Ireland has some of the highest insurance premiums in Europe, with costs rising by 35% over the past five years. Source: Eurostat

  • Market Concentration: The top five insurers control over 70% of the market, limiting competition and consumer choice. Source: Central Bank of Ireland

Understanding these dynamics is essential for stakeholders to navigate the challenges and opportunities in the Irish insurance market.