Online Guides Surpass Print: Can We Trust Them?

May 20
16:04

2024

Elisa Guiducci

Elisa Guiducci

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Share this article on Twitter
  • Share this article on Linkedin

In the midst of a digital revolution, the world is transforming at an unprecedented pace, making changes visible and palpable. New apps eliminate the need for SMS payments, and websites offer dining and drinking at half the cost. This revolution, while overwhelmingly positive, connects people and ideas at lightning speed, though some sectors are less enthusiastic about the web's rapid ascent.

The Digital Shift in Gastronomic Guides

The rise of online platforms has significantly impacted traditional print guides,Online Guides Surpass Print: Can We Trust Them? Articles especially in the gastronomic world. Renowned food critics and their editorial teams are increasingly challenged by self-proclaimed food reviewers who position themselves as new authorities in gourmet criticism. While Italians have long enjoyed playing armchair coaches during World Cup matches, critiquing a dish requires far more nuanced expertise than shouting "Put Del Piero in!" from the sidelines. This shift has put traditional food journalists on high alert against DIY reviews on many websites.

The Battle Between Print and Online Reviews

The primary question is: who is the target reader? It's unlikely that a Gambero Rosso or Michelin reader would replace their trusted guides with, say, TripAdvisor. The real issue lies with the average reader, who straddles the line between online opinions and glossy, bound print news. If print guides are indeed losing ground, it may be due to the lack of pioneering spirit among gourmet journalists. Familiar names dominate, and there's a reluctance to take risks by highlighting emerging young talents.

The Rise of Online Influencers

While established figures like Heinz Beck continue to top the charts, lesser-known journalists like Luigi Pignataro are gaining followers through a more genuine connection with the gastronomic community. Pignataro laments, "We provincial bloggers are never invited to any presentations (except for L’Espresso, summa cum laude to our Vizzarone). I don't expect an invite to Michelin's grand party, but at least Gambero Rosso or Identità Golose should acknowledge us. Gambero Rosso has grown more thanks to the web than to print; often, we're not even invited to the openings of famous restaurants. This means I won't cut anyone any slack!"

The Future of Gastronomic Criticism

Regardless of the medium—print or web—the crucial point is to celebrate and discuss Italy's extraordinary cuisine. The digital age has democratized food criticism, allowing a broader range of voices to be heard. However, this democratization comes with its own set of challenges, including the reliability and expertise of online reviews.

Interesting Statistics

  • Online Reviews Influence: According to a 2020 survey by BrightLocal, 87% of consumers read online reviews for local businesses, including restaurants, before making a decision (BrightLocal).
  • Trust in Online Reviews: A 2019 study by Trustpilot found that 90% of consumers trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations (Trustpilot).
  • Impact on Dining Choices: A 2018 survey by OpenTable revealed that 60% of diners read restaurant reviews before choosing where to eat (OpenTable).

Conclusion

The digital revolution has undeniably transformed the landscape of gastronomic guides. While traditional print guides still hold value, the rise of online reviews has democratized food criticism, making it more accessible but also more contentious. The key is to ensure that, regardless of the medium, the focus remains on celebrating and critiquing the rich tapestry of Italian cuisine.

In the end, whether through print or digital means, the goal is to keep the conversation about Italy's remarkable culinary heritage alive and thriving.