Assessing the Safety of Stevia Sweeteners

Feb 25
18:45

2024

Oswald J. Eppers

Oswald J. Eppers

  • Share this article on Facebook
  • Share this article on Twitter
  • Share this article on Linkedin

Stevia, a natural sweetener derived from the leaves of the Stevia rebaudiana Bertoni plant, has been a subject of debate regarding its safety and regulatory approval. While some countries have embraced it, others have been cautious due to toxicological concerns. However, recent evaluations by food safety authorities are shedding light on the potential for Stevia's acceptance as a safe sugar alternative, albeit with certain restrictions. This article delves into the safety profile of Stevia, comparing it with other sweeteners and examining the scientific evidence that supports its use.

The Origins and Traditional Uses of Stevia

Stevia rebaudiana Bertoni,Assessing the Safety of Stevia Sweeteners Articles often simply referred to as Stevia, has a rich history that dates back to the 16th century when it was first documented by Spanish physician and botanist Pedro Jaime Esteve. Indigenous communities in Paraguay and southern Brazil have used Stevia, known locally as "ka'a he'ê" or "sweet leaf," for centuries as a sweetener in yerba mate and for medicinal purposes, including fertility control.

The Sweet Science Behind Stevia

Stevia leaves are packed with glycosides, which are compounds that combine sugar molecules with a non-carbohydrate component. These glycosides, particularly stevioside and rebaudioside A, are responsible for Stevia's sweetness, which is 250-300 times greater than that of sucrose (table sugar) while containing minimal calories. The body metabolizes these glycosides, releasing sugar molecules and a compound called steviol.

Investigating Steviol's Safety

Concerns about Stevia's safety have centered on steviol, the backbone of Stevia's chemical structure. Early studies suggested that steviol could be genotoxic, meaning it could potentially alter genetic information. However, subsequent research in animals indicated that significant DNA damage would require high concentrations of steviol, much higher than what humans would typically consume.

Stevia's Controversial Effects on Fertility and Cancer Risk

The debate over Stevia's safety gained momentum with studies in the late 20th century. A 1968 study by Professor Joseph Kuc of Purdue University suggested a contraceptive effect in female rats given high doses of Stevia, with fertility rates dropping significantly. Later, a 1999 study by Professor Melis of the University of São Paulo reported reduced sperm counts in male rats after high doses of Stevia glycosides. Despite these findings, the majority of toxicological studies have not confirmed concerns regarding carcinogenicity or mutagenicity.

Regulatory Perspectives on Stevia

Internationally, regulatory stances on Stevia vary. Countries like Japan, China, Australia, New Zealand, Brazil, and Mexico have approved Stevia extracts as natural sweeteners. In Japan, Stevia has been used without reported health issues since 1971. In contrast, the United States, Canada, and the European Union have been more cautious, citing insufficient long-term studies to prove its safety. The FDA has approved Rebaudioside A as Generally Recognized As Safe (GRAS) but not Stevioside.

The European Food Safety Authority's Reevaluation

In April 2010, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) conducted a new assessment of Stevia's toxicological data. This led to the conclusion that Stevioside and Stevia extracts are safe for use as tabletop sweeteners under certain conditions. The EFSA established an acceptable daily intake (ADI) of 4 mg per kilogram of body weight for steviosides, aligning with the World Health Organization's recommendation. This means an adult weighing 70 kg can safely consume 280 mg of Stevia extract daily, equivalent to replacing about 70 grams of sugar.

Comparing Stevia with Aspartame

When comparing Stevia to aspartame, the most widely used synthetic sweetener, it's interesting to note that aspartame's ADI is set at 40 mg/kg of body weight, suggesting that Stevia is perceived to be about 10 times more "toxic" based on available toxicological information. However, this does not necessarily reflect the actual risk associated with normal consumption levels.

Conclusion: The Safety of Stevia Sweeteners

While Stevia is a natural product, it is important to approach its consumption with a critical eye. The notion that natural products are inherently safer is not always supported by scientific evidence. In moderation, Stevia extracts can be considered safe and offer a calorie-free alternative to sugar. As with any food additive, it is essential to adhere to recommended intake levels to avoid potential health risks.

For further information on Stevia and its regulatory status, you can visit the European Food Safety Authority and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration websites.