Art serves as a mirror to the human spirit, reflecting the tumultuous battle between chaos and order, the ethereal and the material. It is a testament to the human condition, a bridge between the abstract and the tangible, and a dialogue that transcends time. This article delves into the profound questions surrounding art's purpose, its creation, and its ability to communicate the incommunicable. Through a conversation between Roberto Calvo Macias and Sam Vaknin, we explore the enigmatic nature of art and its role in human experience.
Roberto Calvo Macias ponders the ancient motivations behind art, questioning whether the Altamira Cave paintings were born of magic, religion, or a nascent abstract thought. He wonders if the cave painter was the first to conceptualize the abstract, or if art was merely a pastime. This curiosity extends to the evaluation of art itself—how do we measure its quality, and what defines a masterpiece?
Roberto reflects on his own transformation, influenced by literary figures like Borges and Neil Gaiman, which sharpened his vision and perhaps bordered on the mystical. He questions the relationship between mental states and artistic quality, pondering if great artists like Vincent Van Gogh were driven by madness or divine inspiration.
Sam Vaknin counters with the notion that art, by its very nature, requires a surrender to form and structure. He argues that even the most anarchic spirit must adhere to the constraints of the medium, whether it's the canvas, the written page, or the musical scale. This inherent order and discipline are crucial to the creation of art.
Roberto challenges the idea that great art can only emerge from a Calvinistic sense of order and discipline. He lists numerous artists known for their anarchic and unstable lives, questioning whether their lack of conventional structure diminishes their artistic achievements.
Sam describes art as the spirit's struggle against imposed form, a rebellion that seeks to capture the world's chaotic beauty. He emphasizes that art is not about beauty per se but about the law of creation, with its cold indifference being the true source of beauty.
Roberto suggests that art's origins lie in the anarchic spirit of childhood, where imagination and innocence reign. He questions why art should be constrained by order when the natural world, like wild horses, possesses an inherent beauty.
Sam argues that art is not about the beauty in the eye of the beholder but about the universal law of creation. He references the mystical tradition of the Kabbalah, which speaks of divine light and broken vessels, to illustrate the duality of the human soul and the role of art in expressing it.
Roberto asserts that art transcends the mundane, touching our hearts with a promise and a shared secret. He believes that art reveals the deeper reality hidden beyond the "Wall of Time," connecting us to the essence of human existence.
Roberto introduces the concept of collective memory, as described by Carl Jung's archetypes, suggesting that art can tap into this shared subconscious to evoke universal emotions and experiences.
Sam acknowledges the potential of art to serve as a communicative bridge, allowing isolated humans to connect through the artist's expression. However, he questions whether art can truly convey a universal meaning, given the subjective nature of individual experiences.
The dialogue concludes with a recognition of art's emotional impact and its ability to resonate with our private languages. Yet, there remains a question of whether art can convey a consistent message to all its beholders. Art, in its complexity, both unites and isolates us, reminding us of the impossibility of perfect communication and the profound solitude of the human experience.
This conversation between Roberto Calvo Macias and Sam Vaknin offers a glimpse into the complex and often contradictory nature of art. It challenges us to consider the ways in which art connects us to our deepest realities, while also confronting us with the limitations of our understanding. As we engage with art, we are invited to explore the depths of our own souls and the collective human spirit, finding solace and meaning in the shared experience of creation.
The Ubiquitous Britannica 2015
Encyclopedia Britannica is now online and as a DVD. The print edition has been discontinued.
Pears Cyclopaedia 2014-5 Edition: Human Knowledge Encapsulated
Pears Cyclopaedia is the last remaining one volume reference work.
Envy as the Foundation of Capitalism
Envy is either destructive, or, as in the case of capitalism, constructive.
