In the ever-evolving world of digital audio workstations (DAWs), music producers and audio engineers are constantly debating which software reigns supreme. From the early days of MIDI sequencing on Atari STs to the sophisticated audio manipulation tools of today, the journey of music production technology has been remarkable. We delve into the experiences of industry veterans Dave Garnish and Al Riley, exploring the capabilities of Logic Pro, Pro Tools, Ableton Live, and Cubase, and how they've shaped the music production landscape.
In the early 1990s, music production was a different beast. MIDI sequencing was primarily done on Atari ST computers, which boasted a mere 512k of RAM. Audio recording was handled by 24-track tape machines, and sampling was revolutionized by the Akai S900 and S1000 series. Steinberg's Cubase and Emagic's Notator (which later became Logic) were the leading sequencers, with Cubase offering a more intuitive user interface for manipulating MIDI data.
As Mac computers entered the scene, they quickly outpaced the Atari ST in terms of stability and capabilities. Emagic Logic, especially around version 3, performed significantly better on Macs, leading to a shift in the industry standard. Dave Garnish, a seasoned mix engineer, recalls the transition from Cubase to Logic and how customizing key commands in Logic gave him a competitive edge.
With the introduction of Macs capable of audio recording and editing, the concept of a DAW began to take shape. The use of multiple Akai S1000 samplers for extensive sample time and the emergence of plugins marked a significant advancement in music production capabilities.
Apple's acquisition of Emagic in 2002 led to significant developments in Logic Pro. Features like the comp tool and loop end tool were introduced, although some users, like Garnish, felt that more input from active music producers could have kept Logic as the top choice DAW.
Ableton Live has gained popularity in the last decade, particularly for its session mode and warp marking capabilities. Logic's Flex Time feature, while useful, is often seen as inferior to Ableton's warping tools. Ableton's intuitive design and suitability for live performance have made it a favorite among producers and DJs.
Cubase has made significant strides in its audio handling, offering unique features that set it apart from competitors. Its improvements in MIDI functionality have also been noteworthy, making it a strong contender in the DAW market.
Pro Tools has long been considered the industry standard, particularly in professional recording studios. Its powerful editing capabilities and workflow geared towards organization have made it indispensable. With the release of Pro Tools 9, which supports any audio interface, Avid has broadened its appeal.
The answer to which DAW is best is subjective and depends on the user's needs and preferences. Pro Tools and Ableton Live are Al Riley's choices, with Pro Tools handling editing and mixing tasks and Ableton being the go-to for composition and idea generation. The overlap between DAWs' capabilities continues to grow, with each offering unique strengths.
In conclusion, the best DAW is the one that fits seamlessly into your workflow and allows you to realize your creative vision. Whether it's the robustness of Pro Tools, the flexibility of Ableton Live, the comprehensive features of Logic Pro, or the unique audio handling of Cubase, each DAW has its place in the music production world.
Approaches to music in Max/MSP
Steve Powell takes a sideways look at electronic composition, comparing the benefits of timeline based sequencers with other perspectives on music creation. Here Steve takes a basic drum-loop and shows new ways to think about rhythm in Max/MSP, and illustrates how rhythm generation can take music in new directions.
THINK, MAKE, PLAY. Max/MSP courses article
Why can inspiration be so difficult at times? Well the could be a very long discussion, but for this article Steve Powell looks into ways to blast the blank page blues and shows how building something from the bare bones up can be a very inspirational journey.
Choosing and Positioning Home Studio Monitor Speakers
This article os about choosing, buying and positioning studio monitor speakers. I talk about nearfield, farfield and brands like Genelec, Auratone, Yamaha NS10's, Mark 'Spike' Stent's KRK 9000's. I explain active and passive studio monitor speakers.
